Trying to have it both ways.......immigration

This graphic is from the FB page, Boycott Koch Industries.



It reflects the contradictions that underpin what the right incorrectly believes about the issue of immigration.  It is part of the pattern of demonizing immigrants, both those who are legal and those who are undocumented. 

It is factually false in BOTH versions in the graphic. 

Immigrants are not stealing jobs from Americans, in fact they provide much labor that would go unperformed otherwise.  And immigrants are not lazy; they want to work, and indeed BOTH legal AND undocumented immigrants start up new businesses at twice the rate of American citizens, AND they pay a significant amount of taxes, including into social security (which they cannot collect from).

While coming to this country benefits those who do so, often those people are fleeing hellish conditions, it is still a less than desirable life to live in the shadows.  We NEED immigration reform.  We should be treating these people with compassion (except for those who are criminals like those who willingly - as distinct from unwillingly through coercion - work for drug cartels etc.).

As with the famous Bible quote (John 8:32) about the truth setting you free, the truth, the FACTS, about immigration and why it is GOOD for the United States could set a lot of people free - not only the immigrants themselves, but those who harbor ill will towards them without legitimate foundation to do so.

Because the issue of immigration is so central to the political right wing in 2015 and 2016 elections, it is imperative that we correct the misinformation and propaganda deception of the right wing voters with solid facts and effective persuasion.  Not doing so, successfully, will harm all of us, not just the right, not just immigrants, but ALL of us, as a nation.

It won't be easy to do, but it is important to do.  Please, start with sharing this.  Hopefully the Schrodinger reference will be understood and the humor will help be persuasive, when put so graphically.

Prayer for Koch Industries, Is Capitalism the New Religion of the Religious Right?

I received this email from a friend who is an occasional reader, who noted that I had recently written about the apparent lack of intellectual honesty evidenced by the finding of the Koch/von Hayek correspondence here.  Also I had written about the Bloomberg News Report on Koch here.

Compared to say anyone on Fox News, or other right wing media, particularly of the Rupert Murdoch owned variety, or pundit entertainers like Rush Limbaugh, or the majority of the right wing blogosphere, Bloomberg does a competent job of being factual.  I have no doubt whatsoever that Bloomberg is going to proceed with extra care when going up against Koch Industries, who have 'deep pockets'.  The political right is notoriously litigious.

Not that Bloomberg is either a Democrat or a liberal; while he started out as a Democrat in the last millennium, he's been a Republican through most of the past decade, including his political career, before switching from being a Republican to an Independent in 2007.

So while the New York mayor and media mogul is not anywhere as far right as the Koch brothers (well, two out of three of them anyway), he is a fairly centrist individual with some respectable Republican credentials.

So it was with that in mind that I perused with great skepticism the following email (redacted to preserve the privacy of the sender) which I am assured did in fact come directly from the wife of a Koch employee rather than as a chain email:

Subject: Prayer for Koch persecution

Hello Sisters,      I'm writing to ask for an urgent prayer request.  We're doing fine, but Koch, the company we work for has need.  They have been ruthlessly persecuted over the past 2 years by the liberal media and followers of leftist ideologies.  Those people know they must somehow attack and discredit one of the most successful representations of the Free Market Enterprise that has made this country great.  There have been numerous articles and allegations of all sorts and tomorrow morning on ABC's Good Morning America, they'll be doing another "hatchet job".         These lies and misrepresentation can have strong repercussions.  Please pray that the viewers will see the truth and the obvious slant of the enemy.  And that they would "wake-up" to the destruction of our Liberties in the United States.          And please point anyone who needs to, to go to this website for Koch's side of the story:  www.kochfacts.com.            I so appreciate your prayers and any others you make for the continued upholding of our Nation's Freedoms and Liberties!      May God be Merciful,

Now I'm far more likely to be praying vigorously for a bit of Koch Industries PROSECUTION, rather than to save them from any perceived 'persecution'. 

In my usual interest in fact checking, I have not only begun my own fact check effort, but also forwarded this on, including the linked page, to politifact.com, in the hopes they will take a whack at fact checking BOTH Bloomberg and the Koch Industries claims. 

Which, should they take up the challenge, I will of course post here.

I'm hoping I might tempt my mikeb co-blogger, Laci, into working with me, on my own efforts; because this might be beyond my own humble resources.  I'm hoping Laci's background might be uniquely suited to the international and legal aspects, but I also respect that his time is valuable and there are many other demands on it.

But most of all, I was struck by what amounts to a new religion that equates greed to god, and predatory capitalism to patriotism and representative democracy.  Beyond the specific challenges over fact are the extremely disturbing Libertarian leaning assumptions about economics, government, religion, and most of all, the presumption that other Americans who disagree with their extreme right wing positions ARE THE ENEMY.  That word was used specifically; the author of this email sees people like me, like Pen, like Laci as their ENEMY rather than simply people who differ from them.

The sheer intolerance of that, the paranoiac world view of that passage is deeply disturbing to me.  That it might very well derive, in the case of the email, from a misleading representation of the facts by Koch Industries is equally disturbing.

This represents a kind of political engagement that was new in the days of the so-called moral majority in the 90's - a group of people who were neither particularly moral, nor any kind of majority, and it has continued to evolve as the religious right during the 2000s.  And by evolve, what I really mean is to become more extreme and more intolerant and less reality based.  In other words, crazier than they were before.

So I am contemplating this fact check endeavor as a push-back against the intolerant, against the bogus religious associations of greed and God, and against the unwarranted paranoia of the right represented by this email.

 I'm tempted to begin with a prayer for the prosecution - and even for a little persecution to happen TO the Koch Brothers and Koch Industries, for my personal inspiration and as a touch of humor to the otherwise dry business of fact checking.